When a dinosaur gets the best scene in the script
Michael Crichton had a pretty good idea in WESTWORLD. Build a high-tech amusement park, put people inside, and then have the attractions start killing the customers.
He liked the idea enough to use it again. WESTWORLD gave us malfunctioning robots. JURASSIC PARK gave us genetically engineered dinosaurs. Same basic nightmare. Considerably better teeth. I wrote a post about Crichton's ability to get two enormous commercial successes out of one concept, and I still think that's pretty impressive.
The JURASSIC PARK movie is terrific. Spielberg gets the wonder, the horror, and the sheer size of these creatures across in a way that still holds up. But look at the ending from the point of view of somebody writing a screenplay.
Alan Grant, Ellie Sattler, and the children are cornered by velociraptors in the visitor center. Grant has been protecting the kids through one dangerous situation after another. Ellie has risked her life. Everybody is out of good ideas. The raptors are about to have dinner.
Then the T. rex arrives and attacks the raptors.
Problem solved. Or at least the humans now have time to escape while the dinosaurs have a disagreement over the menu.
The wonderful final touch is the banner falling around the T. rex: WHEN DINOSAURS RULED THE EARTH. Great image. Great audience moment. The dinosaur gets the big finish and our protagonists run for the door.
Here's what bothers me: Grant doesn't do anything to cause that rescue. He doesn't lure the T. rex into the building or set up a confrontation between the animals. The T. rex just happens to arrive at precisely the right time. Lucky for the humans. Less impressive as a character-driven climax.
Is it deus ex machina? Strictly speaking, the dinosaur isn't a new element invented at the end to solve a script problem. We've seen her before. We know the fences are down and the park has fallen apart. She's roaming around doing exactly what you'd expect a large predator to do. That's a legitimate defense.
There's an even stronger defense. The entire movie is about the arrogance of believing nature can be controlled. Hammond and his people can bring dinosaurs back from extinction, put price tags on them, and sell tickets. They cannot make nature behave. So nature gets the last word. The T. rex doesn't arrive as a friend of Alan Grant. She's just another dangerous animal, and the humans benefit from the timing.
That's good thematic writing. It's also a mighty convenient rescue.
Crichton's novel makes for an interesting comparison. Grant has a more direct role in confronting the raptors, including using poisoned eggs. The book doesn't end with a T. rex bursting into the visitor center to save the day. The movie's solution is a deliberate adaptation choice. The screenplay credits Michael Crichton and David Koepp, so I'm not going to pretend I know which of them suggested it.
Would I change Spielberg's ending? Maybe not. I can picture the story conference: 'What if Grant sets a trap for the raptors?' Fine, but now the climax is about Grant outsmarting dinosaurs. The movie's larger idea is that nobody, however clever, is in control of these animals.
What I might have asked for is one character-defining choice that creates the opening for escape. Grant could make a decision, take a genuine risk, and still have nature finish the job. His agency would matter without turning him into a dinosaur whisperer.
Of course, it's easy to give notes on one of the biggest hits ever made. Spielberg could reasonably reply that millions of people cheered when that T. rex appeared. He's got a point.
But box office isn't the same thing as a screenwriting principle. A climax can be thrilling and still depend on an extraordinary coincidence. JURASSIC PARK is both. The writer's job is to know the difference.
Film credits: JURASSIC PARK (1993), directed by Steven Spielberg. Screenplay by Michael Crichton and David Koepp; based on Crichton’s novel.