An ending where the hero actually forces the outcome
I've been picking on Spielberg for ending some very good movies with the hero being saved by somebody or something else. God in RAIDERS. A T. rex in JURASSIC PARK. A microscopic army in WAR OF THE WORLDS.
So I suppose it's only fair to point out a Spielberg film that does nearly the opposite. MINORITY REPORT.
This is a wonderful premise. In the future, the police can arrest you for a murder you haven't committed yet. Three 'precogs' predict the crime and a special police unit stops it before it happens. No body. No trial for murder. Just the comforting knowledge that the government knows what you're going to do before you do it.
As a lawyer, I can think of a few problems with this arrangement.
John Anderton, played by Tom Cruise, believes in the system. He's running Precrime and has convinced himself that the predictions are reliable. Then the precogs predict that HE will murder a man. Nothing like becoming the defendant to make you reconsider a theory of law enforcement.
That's your central dramatic engine. Anderton has a concrete goal: find out what's going on before he's arrested for an act he hasn't committed. He encounters obstacles, makes choices, and discovers that the machinery behind Precrime is not nearly as pure as its advocates claim.
The key is his discovery of the murder of Anne Lively, Agatha's mother, and the role Lamar Burgess played in covering it up. Burgess presents himself as a visionary public servant. He's actually willing to murder to protect the institution he created. There's a little irony for you.
Now look at the ending. Anderton doesn't sit there waiting for a dinosaur to wander into the room. He confronts Burgess with the truth, and he forces him to make a choice.
Burgess can shoot Anderton, fulfilling the predicted murder and exposing himself as a killer. Or he can refuse to shoot, undermining Precrime's claim that the predicted future is inevitable. Either way, the system is in trouble. Burgess ultimately takes his own life.
Notice what caused that ending. Anderton investigated the murder. He found the evidence. He confronted the man responsible and put him in a position where his own decisions would expose the lie. Burgess pulls the trigger, but it's Anderton who forces the confrontation.
That's protagonist agency. The hero doesn't have to fire the final shot. He has to do something that makes the ending happen.
Is MINORITY REPORT perfect? No. There are some conveniences in the plot and the final wrap-up is awfully tidy. You could also argue that Burgess had other ways to respond. People, especially corrupt politicians and powerful bureaucrats, aren't always obliging about choosing between the two options the hero gives them. But at least the decisive turn follows the protagonist's actions.
The movie also proves why a simple rule about deus ex machina doesn't get us very far. Spielberg sometimes wants to show human beings confronting something beyond their control. Other times he's interested in one person exposing a machine built by other people. Those are different stories and they ought to have different endings.
When I read a screenplay, one of the things I look for is whether the hero is still driving the story in the final act. What does he want? What's stopping him? What does he do to overcome it? The third act should not be the place where the protagonist gets demoted to spectator.
Anderton is no spectator. He drives the final confrontation, takes his chances, and exposes a murderer. No cavalry required.
Unless you count Tom Cruise. And for the studio, I suppose he counts as cavalry.
Film credits: MINORITY REPORT (2002), directed by Steven Spielberg. Screenplay by Scott Frank and Jon Cohen; based on Philip K. Dick’s 1956 short story.