Pages

Sunday, November 22, 2026

MINORITY REPORT: NO DINOSAUR REQUIRED

 An ending where the hero actually forces the outcome

I've been picking on Spielberg for ending some very good movies with the hero being saved by somebody or something else. God in RAIDERS. A T. rex in JURASSIC PARK. A microscopic army in WAR OF THE WORLDS.

So I suppose it's only fair to point out a Spielberg film that does nearly the opposite. MINORITY REPORT.

This is a wonderful premise. In the future, the police can arrest you for a murder you haven't committed yet. Three 'precogs' predict the crime and a special police unit stops it before it happens. No body. No trial for murder. Just the comforting knowledge that the government knows what you're going to do before you do it.

As a lawyer, I can think of a few problems with this arrangement.

John Anderton, played by Tom Cruise, believes in the system. He's running Precrime and has convinced himself that the predictions are reliable. Then the precogs predict that HE will murder a man. Nothing like becoming the defendant to make you reconsider a theory of law enforcement.

That's your central dramatic engine. Anderton has a concrete goal: find out what's going on before he's arrested for an act he hasn't committed. He encounters obstacles, makes choices, and discovers that the machinery behind Precrime is not nearly as pure as its advocates claim.

The key is his discovery of the murder of Anne Lively, Agatha's mother, and the role Lamar Burgess played in covering it up. Burgess presents himself as a visionary public servant. He's actually willing to murder to protect the institution he created. There's a little irony for you.

Now look at the ending. Anderton doesn't sit there waiting for a dinosaur to wander into the room. He confronts Burgess with the truth, and he forces him to make a choice.

Burgess can shoot Anderton, fulfilling the predicted murder and exposing himself as a killer. Or he can refuse to shoot, undermining Precrime's claim that the predicted future is inevitable. Either way, the system is in trouble. Burgess ultimately takes his own life.

Notice what caused that ending. Anderton investigated the murder. He found the evidence. He confronted the man responsible and put him in a position where his own decisions would expose the lie. Burgess pulls the trigger, but it's Anderton who forces the confrontation.

That's protagonist agency. The hero doesn't have to fire the final shot. He has to do something that makes the ending happen.

Is MINORITY REPORT perfect? No. There are some conveniences in the plot and the final wrap-up is awfully tidy. You could also argue that Burgess had other ways to respond. People, especially corrupt politicians and powerful bureaucrats, aren't always obliging about choosing between the two options the hero gives them. But at least the decisive turn follows the protagonist's actions.

The movie also proves why a simple rule about deus ex machina doesn't get us very far. Spielberg sometimes wants to show human beings confronting something beyond their control. Other times he's interested in one person exposing a machine built by other people. Those are different stories and they ought to have different endings.

When I read a screenplay, one of the things I look for is whether the hero is still driving the story in the final act. What does he want? What's stopping him? What does he do to overcome it? The third act should not be the place where the protagonist gets demoted to spectator.

Anderton is no spectator. He drives the final confrontation, takes his chances, and exposes a murderer. No cavalry required.

Unless you count Tom Cruise. And for the studio, I suppose he counts as cavalry.

Film credits: MINORITY REPORT (2002), directed by Steven Spielberg. Screenplay by Scott Frank and Jon Cohen; based on Philip K. Dick’s 1956 short story.

Friday, November 20, 2026

WAR OF THE WORLDS: GERMS SAVE THE DAY

 Spielberg gets the blame. H. G. Wells got there first.

In RAIDERS OF THE LOST ARK, God finishes off the Nazis. In JURASSIC PARK, a T. rex arrives just in time to rescue our heroes. In WAR OF THE WORLDS, the invading aliens are defeated by bacteria.

God. Dinosaurs. Germs. Spielberg has assembled a rather unusual rescue squad.

Now before we accuse him of writing himself out of a corner, we ought to give credit where it's due. The ending of WAR OF THE WORLDS was written by H. G. Wells in 1898. Spielberg's 2005 film keeps it. It's not a last-minute Spielberg invention, and the point Wells was making is a lot more interesting than 'we ran out of ideas.'

The aliens have machines that can destroy cities and weapons that render human armies useless. They apparently gave some thought to interplanetary travel and conquest. What they overlooked was the local health department. Earth's microorganisms do what all those tanks and soldiers could not.

Wells was writing about invasion and empire, and he turns the whole idea of conquest on its head. The supposedly superior invaders can't even survive the planet they've come to own. There's a pretty sharp joke buried in that premise, although humanity isn't laughing while the tripods are operating.

The other issue is this: Who is the protagonist and what is HIS story?

Ray Ferrier, played by Tom Cruise, isn't a scientist trying to discover the aliens' weakness. He's a father who hasn't been particularly good at being one. When the invasion begins, his assignment is to keep his children alive. That's the movie we're watching, even while the larger catastrophe takes place all around him.

Ray makes some ugly decisions. He kills the man hiding with him and his daughter when that man's behavior becomes a danger to them. He later fights back inside an alien machine. These aren't passive actions. The guy is trying, often desperately, to save his family. But he doesn't figure out the secret of the invaders or single-handedly save the world.

He isn't supposed to.

A character can win his personal story without winning the war. In fact, if Ray suddenly developed a biological weapon and defeated the invaders, we'd be watching a completely different film. Probably one with a military scientist, a government briefing, and a lot more dialogue about pathogens.

The germs are a defensible ending. The bigger problem for me is Robbie.

Ray's son races off toward the military action and disappears into an inferno. The film seems to be telling us that Ray has lost him. That's a terrible thing for a parent to confront, and the scene has real emotional weight.

Then, at the end, Robbie is standing there safe and sound with the family in Boston.

Huh?

How did he survive? How did he get to Boston? There may be perfectly plausible answers, but the film doesn't bother giving us one. He's just back. We had the traumatic loss and now we get the happy reunion, without having to endure the consequences in between.

That's the moment when I feel a writer putting a thumb on the scale. Wells's germs are part of the premise and the theme. Robbie's miraculous return looks a lot more like somebody wanting an emotional payoff without paying the full price for it.

The distinction is worth keeping in mind. Deus ex machina doesn't simply mean 'the protagonist wasn't the one who killed the bad guy.' A story can be about the limits of human control. But it still has to honor the promises it makes to its audience.

I'll buy that microbes defeated the aliens. H. G. Wells made the case more than a century ago. I'm still waiting to hear how Robbie got through that battle.

Film credits: WAR OF THE WORLDS (2005), directed by Steven Spielberg. Screenplay by Josh Friedman and David Koepp; based on H. G. Wells’s 1898 novel.


 

Thursday, November 19, 2026

JURASSIC PARK: DEUS EX T. REX

 When a dinosaur gets the best scene in the script

Michael Crichton had a pretty good idea in WESTWORLD. Build a high-tech amusement park, put people inside, and then have the attractions start killing the customers.

He liked the idea enough to use it again. WESTWORLD gave us malfunctioning robots. JURASSIC PARK gave us genetically engineered dinosaurs. Same basic nightmare. Considerably better teeth. I wrote a post about Crichton's ability to get two enormous commercial successes out of one concept, and I still think that's pretty impressive.

The JURASSIC PARK movie is terrific. Spielberg gets the wonder, the horror, and the sheer size of these creatures across in a way that still holds up. But look at the ending from the point of view of somebody writing a screenplay.

Alan Grant, Ellie Sattler, and the children are cornered by velociraptors in the visitor center. Grant has been protecting the kids through one dangerous situation after another. Ellie has risked her life. Everybody is out of good ideas. The raptors are about to have dinner.

Then the T. rex arrives and attacks the raptors.

Problem solved. Or at least the humans now have time to escape while the dinosaurs have a disagreement over the menu.

The wonderful final touch is the banner falling around the T. rex: WHEN DINOSAURS RULED THE EARTH. Great image. Great audience moment. The dinosaur gets the big finish and our protagonists run for the door.

Here's what bothers me: Grant doesn't do anything to cause that rescue. He doesn't lure the T. rex into the building or set up a confrontation between the animals. The T. rex just happens to arrive at precisely the right time. Lucky for the humans. Less impressive as a character-driven climax.

Is it deus ex machina? Strictly speaking, the dinosaur isn't a new element invented at the end to solve a script problem. We've seen her before. We know the fences are down and the park has fallen apart. She's roaming around doing exactly what you'd expect a large predator to do. That's a legitimate defense.

There's an even stronger defense. The entire movie is about the arrogance of believing nature can be controlled. Hammond and his people can bring dinosaurs back from extinction, put price tags on them, and sell tickets. They cannot make nature behave. So nature gets the last word. The T. rex doesn't arrive as a friend of Alan Grant. She's just another dangerous animal, and the humans benefit from the timing.

That's good thematic writing. It's also a mighty convenient rescue.

Crichton's novel makes for an interesting comparison. Grant has a more direct role in confronting the raptors, including using poisoned eggs. The book doesn't end with a T. rex bursting into the visitor center to save the day. The movie's solution is a deliberate adaptation choice. The screenplay credits Michael Crichton and David Koepp, so I'm not going to pretend I know which of them suggested it.

Would I change Spielberg's ending? Maybe not. I can picture the story conference: 'What if Grant sets a trap for the raptors?' Fine, but now the climax is about Grant outsmarting dinosaurs. The movie's larger idea is that nobody, however clever, is in control of these animals.

What I might have asked for is one character-defining choice that creates the opening for escape. Grant could make a decision, take a genuine risk, and still have nature finish the job. His agency would matter without turning him into a dinosaur whisperer.

Of course, it's easy to give notes on one of the biggest hits ever made. Spielberg could reasonably reply that millions of people cheered when that T. rex appeared. He's got a point.

But box office isn't the same thing as a screenwriting principle. A climax can be thrilling and still depend on an extraordinary coincidence. JURASSIC PARK is both. The writer's job is to know the difference.

Film credits: JURASSIC PARK (1993), directed by Steven Spielberg. Screenplay by Michael Crichton and David Koepp; based on Crichton’s novel.


 

Wednesday, November 18, 2026

RAIDERS OF THE LOST ARK: DOES INDIANA JONES ACTUALLY WIN?

 A rocket launcher, a bad plan, and a little help from above

I love RAIDERS OF THE LOST ARK. The opening sequence is a small course in visual storytelling. The truck chase is one of the best action sequences ever put on film. If somebody asked me to recommend a movie for a beginning screenwriter to study, RAIDERS would be near the top of the list.

That said, I've always had a problem with the ending.

Here's the question: What exactly does Indiana Jones do to defeat Belloq and the Nazis?

Think about the rocket launcher scene. Indy has tracked the Nazis to their base and appears above them with a rocket launcher. Free Marion, he demands, or he'll blow up the Ark. Pretty good image. Harrison Ford looks terrific holding that thing. As a plan? Not so terrific.

Belloq knows Indy won't destroy the greatest archaeological find of his life. He calls the bluff. Indy lowers the launcher. The Nazis take him prisoner. End of Plan A. Apparently nobody bothered with Plan B.

And suppose Belloq had released Marion. Then what? Were Indy and Marion supposed to walk past an entire detachment of armed Nazis, hail a cab, and go home? I would have liked to see somebody explain that part of the escape plan.

Belloq keeps his rival alive because he wants Indy to see him open the Ark. I can accept that. Belloq is vain and obsessed with proving himself superior to Jones. He'd enjoy having an audience of one. But the result is that our action hero is tied to a post, unable to do anything to prevent what happens next.

And what happens next? God destroys the Nazis.

The term deus ex machina comes from the ancient theater, where a god could be lowered onto the stage by a machine to solve the characters' troubles. In RAIDERS the god is already in the box. That ought to count for something.

Now, before someone sends me an angry note, the ending is not an unprepared trick. The film has been telling us all along that the Ark has enormous and dangerous power. Belloq and the Nazis believe they can control it. Indy, at the critical moment, recognizes that they can't. He orders Marion to close her eyes. She does, and they survive.

That is a genuine character choice. Indy saves Marion. He's also learned something that Belloq hasn't: some things are better left alone. There's your thematic payoff.

But notice the difference. Indiana Jones saves Marion. The Ark defeats Belloq. The Nazis would have been destroyed whether Indy was tied to that post or back at the university grading papers. He has no real control over the outcome of the external conflict.

Is that bad writing? Not necessarily. I don't think a hero has to kill every villain personally. Nor would I particularly want to see Indiana Jones defeat divine wrath with a whip. The Ark is supposed to be beyond human control. Making Indy master it would probably be a worse ending.

Still, this is a useful exercise for writers. Get out your screenplay and turn to the last ten pages. What does your protagonist actually DO to cause the resolution? Not what does he watch happen. Not what does the villain foolishly do to himself. What choice does your hero make that changes the outcome?

You can decide the answer is 'nothing' because your story is about a character learning the limits of his power. Fine. Make it a conscious choice and pay off the character's journey in some other way.

RAIDERS does that better than most movies could. I still think the rocket-launcher plan needed another draft.

Film credits: RAIDERS OF THE LOST ARK (1981), directed by Steven Spielberg. Screenplay by Lawrence Kasdan; story by George Lucas and Philip Kaufman.


 

Sunday, July 28, 2024

"Don't kiss the newborn baby!"

 Newborns have soft skin and are squishy little cute suckers. But here's something you learn as a new parent: don't let anyone kiss your newborn baby. They haven't built immunity and that kiss can, in fact, be deadly. 

Anyone even holding a newborn should wash hands and, these days, mask up.

What's that got to do with screenwriting?

We have a loosely formed idea for a story. Some characters; some situations; and some early possibilities for story beats. What do we do? We try to tell our story idea to a friend, partner, mentor, and... it falls apart. We let someone kiss the baby!

Wait until you've worked out a treatment, and story beats, you want something fully formed in your own mind before you share it.

Well-meaning friends may derail your story, suggest something they'd write instead, or just crap on your idea destroying the enthusiasm it takes to pursue any artistic endeavor.  

They can enjoy the toddler version of your story. Until then, no kissing!