Pages

Wednesday, November 18, 2026

RAIDERS OF THE LOST ARK: DOES INDIANA JONES ACTUALLY WIN?

 A rocket launcher, a bad plan, and a little help from above

I love RAIDERS OF THE LOST ARK. The opening sequence is a small course in visual storytelling. The truck chase is one of the best action sequences ever put on film. If somebody asked me to recommend a movie for a beginning screenwriter to study, RAIDERS would be near the top of the list.

That said, I've always had a problem with the ending.

Here's the question: What exactly does Indiana Jones do to defeat Belloq and the Nazis?

Think about the rocket launcher scene. Indy has tracked the Nazis to their base and appears above them with a rocket launcher. Free Marion, he demands, or he'll blow up the Ark. Pretty good image. Harrison Ford looks terrific holding that thing. As a plan? Not so terrific.

Belloq knows Indy won't destroy the greatest archaeological find of his life. He calls the bluff. Indy lowers the launcher. The Nazis take him prisoner. End of Plan A. Apparently nobody bothered with Plan B.

And suppose Belloq had released Marion. Then what? Were Indy and Marion supposed to walk past an entire detachment of armed Nazis, hail a cab, and go home? I would have liked to see somebody explain that part of the escape plan.

Belloq keeps his rival alive because he wants Indy to see him open the Ark. I can accept that. Belloq is vain and obsessed with proving himself superior to Jones. He'd enjoy having an audience of one. But the result is that our action hero is tied to a post, unable to do anything to prevent what happens next.

And what happens next? God destroys the Nazis.

The term deus ex machina comes from the ancient theater, where a god could be lowered onto the stage by a machine to solve the characters' troubles. In RAIDERS the god is already in the box. That ought to count for something.

Now, before someone sends me an angry note, the ending is not an unprepared trick. The film has been telling us all along that the Ark has enormous and dangerous power. Belloq and the Nazis believe they can control it. Indy, at the critical moment, recognizes that they can't. He orders Marion to close her eyes. She does, and they survive.

That is a genuine character choice. Indy saves Marion. He's also learned something that Belloq hasn't: some things are better left alone. There's your thematic payoff.

But notice the difference. Indiana Jones saves Marion. The Ark defeats Belloq. The Nazis would have been destroyed whether Indy was tied to that post or back at the university grading papers. He has no real control over the outcome of the external conflict.

Is that bad writing? Not necessarily. I don't think a hero has to kill every villain personally. Nor would I particularly want to see Indiana Jones defeat divine wrath with a whip. The Ark is supposed to be beyond human control. Making Indy master it would probably be a worse ending.

Still, this is a useful exercise for writers. Get out your screenplay and turn to the last ten pages. What does your protagonist actually DO to cause the resolution? Not what does he watch happen. Not what does the villain foolishly do to himself. What choice does your hero make that changes the outcome?

You can decide the answer is 'nothing' because your story is about a character learning the limits of his power. Fine. Make it a conscious choice and pay off the character's journey in some other way.

RAIDERS does that better than most movies could. I still think the rocket-launcher plan needed another draft.

Film credits: RAIDERS OF THE LOST ARK (1981), directed by Steven Spielberg. Screenplay by Lawrence Kasdan; story by George Lucas and Philip Kaufman.


 

Sunday, July 28, 2024

"Don't kiss the newborn baby!"

 Newborns have soft skin and are squishy little cute suckers. But here's something you learn as a new parent: don't let anyone kiss your newborn baby. They haven't built immunity and that kiss can, in fact, be deadly. 

Anyone even holding a newborn should wash hands and, these days, mask up.

What's that got to do with screenwriting?

We have a loosely formed idea for a story. Some characters; some situations; and some early possibilities for story beats. What do we do? We try to tell our story idea to a friend, partner, mentor, and... it falls apart. We let someone kiss the baby!

Wait until you've worked out a treatment, and story beats, you want something fully formed in your own mind before you share it.

Well-meaning friends may derail your story, suggest something they'd write instead, or just crap on your idea destroying the enthusiasm it takes to pursue any artistic endeavor.  

They can enjoy the toddler version of your story. Until then, no kissing!



Saturday, July 27, 2024

There's No On-Ramp into the Industry

 Learning to drive is stressful and, if you can avoid it, never teach someone to drive. You'll have at least one near miss, and at least three screaming fits. Send them to a driving school. 

That said, one of the most important things you learn driving is MERGING INTO TRAFFIC. This can be particularly stressful even for seasoned drivers as you merge into fast-moving interstate traffic. You're going up the on-ramp at 30-40 m.p.h. and now you've got to merge into traffic going 70 p.m., or. more as most regard speed signs as mere suggestions. 

What do you do? You're tempted to slow down to a stop and wait for a spot when it's all clear. But in a busy city... it'll never be all clear. Plus, there's traffic behind you trying to do the same thing. It's stressful and dangerous, and your split-second decisions can have a lifetime (or deathtime) impact.

You must speed up to the prevailing speed of the traffic and - somehow - merge onto the interstate.  

So, what's this got to do with screenwriting? Or any writing? 

We're competing with professionals. Getting my M.F.A. a few years ago at U.G.A. I realized that nobody has ever "made it" in the industry. Every writer - even those with big past success - is hustling for the next gig and is one flop away from irrelevancy. You have heat, you lose heat, and few can regain heat again once lost.

We have to speed up to merge. We have to improve the quality of our writing to a professional level, or it'll get run over. It'll get cast aside quickly as "not pro-level" execution. It isn't enough anymore to just have a great concept. You have to execute it at a professional level. 

For me, that's draft after draft - with pro-quality coverage notes between drafts - and 30 to 40 drafts later I've got something ready to be seen.   

Tuesday, July 23, 2024

"It's art..."

 I recently scored a "Double Recommend" from Stage 32. This read was done by a development exec and the "recommend" score is a top 1% evaluation. These readers often have read thousands of scripts.  The "double" is when they recommend both the script AND the writer.  Seems odd you'd get one but not the other ... but they're different categories in the evaluation. Stage 32 sends out an email blast promoting the project, which will generate reads.

I addressed the notes that were included in the "double recommend" and did yet another draft.  Then got a "meh" reaction with even more notes from the next reader.  

I tend to "box car" reads - do one; address those notes; do the next; then repeat.  Thirty to forty drafts later... should be scoring "recommend" consistently.  But not always.

My kvetching to a friend about this who is a contest administrator led to this response:

"It's art!"

"Huh?" 

"Go look on Rotten Tomatoes.  A hundred critics will be widely divided on the same film and the audience may be on a completely different page than them. It's art. Everyone has an opinion."

"Ugh!"

So, that said, what do we as creatives do to navigate all this?

We follow our instincts and do the best job we can do. If you agree with a note - even if your draft has scored highly - address the note. Incorporate what is useful to make your script the best it can be. That's all we can do.

Not everyone is going to love your story. Not everyone is meant to love your story. You'll find your fans and your tribe. You'll find readers who have your back and help you see weaknesses in the story or character development. And you'll make it the best you can make it.

Then move on to the next story and do it again...

Saturday, April 2, 2022

FREE Pixar Storytelling Course

 The brilliant minds at Pixar posted a great (FREE) series at Kahn Academy on storytelling. 


A must-watch for storytellers:


Kahn Academy Pixar Storytelling Course


The Link Posted above goes here:


https://www.khanacademy.org/computing/pixar/storytelling